|
|
|
|
Answer:
Lead wheel weights are used to balance tires on vehicles with very
little thought about the metal used to make the weight. Lead is one
of the top three hazardous waste materials listed by the
Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability
Act (CERCLA or Superfund) (http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/cxcx3.html).
Lead adversely affects the environment, animals, and humans. The US
EPA estimates that 10% of lead wheel weights fall off during normal
driving conditions and remain on the road (U.S. Geological Survey.
|
|
Answer:
People seemed to have minimal awareness that lead was used in wheel
weights. This fact went under the radar of even the Iowa Department
of Natural Resources (IDNR) (e-mail communication on 9/8/2008). Lead
wheel weights may form the same deadly compounds that are contained
in lead paint. We wondered why another substance wasn’t used in
place of lead in wheel weights. We know how potentially harmful
exposure to lead can be, and we saw an article from |
|
Answer:
Everyone in our community will benefit from our efforts to phase out
lead in wheel weights. Children and wildlife will especially benefit
from our efforts because exposure to lead detrimentally affects the
development of the brain. Adults who work in tire service centers
will benefit because they will have less occupational exposure to
lead. |
|
Answer:
Wheel weights are metal clips that attach to vehicle tires to
balance the tires. Since the 1930’s, lead has been the preferred
substance for wheel weights. Lead affects the nervous, circulatory
and reproductive systems (www.atsdr.cdc.gov). People who work with
large amounts of lead are 3.4 times more likely to develop
Alzheimer’s disease (www.ehponline.org). Lead can decrease a
person’s IQ by up to 3 points for every microgram per deciliter of
blood (www.mass.gov). Lead accumulates in soil and sediment, which
retards growth and reproduction rates of plants and animals. Lead
bioaccumulates in fish, which can work its
way up the food chain. We read an article by Dr. Robert Root: “Lead
Loading of Urban Streets by Motor Vehicle Wheel Weights”. This
article and our correspondence with Dr. Root helped us understand
the significant problem that lead wheel weights pose to the
environment. Dr Root’s study shows how easily discarded wheel
weights abrade and disintegrate into particles or dust that can be
then picked up by shoes and tires or be washed away by rain into
sewers. Lead particles picked up by shoes, tires, etc can then be
carried back into the garage and homes. This led us to wonder why so
little was being done to regulate the entry of lead into the
environment as a result of lead wheel weights. Through our
communications with Linda Barr, US EPA, we learned that the EPA
launched the National Lead-Free Wheel Weight Initiative (NLFWWI) on
Aug. 29, 2008. The purpose of the NLFWWI is to encourage the
voluntary transition away from the use of lead in wheel weights. We
learned that there are alternative metals in place of lead that can
be used for wheel weights. Alternatives include steel, copper, and
aluminum. We also contacted Theresa Stiner, Iowa DNR, to inquire about current
regulations that exist regarding lead wheel weights. We learned
there are no specific regulations in |
|
Answer:
If the public becomes more aware of the environmental dangers of
lead wheel weights and is given alternative wheel balancing choices
then there will be a decrease in lead entering the
environment.
|
|
Answer:
In our town there are approximately 1,700 cars and trucks. Each
vehicle has about 127 grams (4.5 ounces) of lead wheel weights on
their tires. Approximately 10% of lead wheel weights fall off during
normal driving conditions (U.S. Geological Survey. USA Today, August
28, 2008), resulting in about 2.2 kg (5 pounds) of lead being
deposited on the streets. Groundwater and surface water may be
contaminated through street water runoff and children may come in
contact with lead carried into homes on shoes and tires. Therefore,
if our hypothesis is correct, our community will be safer because
there will be less potential for lead contamination of our
groundwater. There will also be decreased risk for lead poisoning of
our citizens through contact with lead wheel weights. |
|
Answer:
To further our understanding of how lead may be released into the
environment, we designed experiments to determine lead solubility
under typical |
|
Answer:
Our initial tests showed that lead was present in three solutions:
rainwater with a lead wheel weight, vinegar with a lead wheel weight
and salt/sand with a lead wheel weight. The lead indicator test kits
we used only confirmed the presence of lead. The testing at the UHL
would measure the amount of lead in the solutions. All of the
control solutions, the distilled water with a lead wheel weight and
the experimental solutions with steel wheel weights did not contain
detectable levels of lead in the initial testing. See data table I.
The UHL test results indicated that significant amounts of soluble
lead were present in all of the non control wheel weight lead
experimental solutions. Dr. Wichman
stated, “Based on these results one can determine that various
conditions could result in leaching of lead from wheel weights. How
that models into contamination of groundwater and/or surface water
requires more research.” Lead concentrate data tables were
constructed based on the total lead concentrate measured by Dr.
Wichman from the wheel weight lead and non
lead testing solutions. We hypothesized that this experimental
information could help us determine the solubility of lead under
various conditions and gain a basic understanding of how hazardous
lead could potentially be released into the environment. With the
exception of the distilled water, the control solutions had trace
amounts of lead present, less than 0.001 mg/L (distilled water) to
0.022 mg/L (Dilute Vinegar solution). The solutions with the steel
wheel weights contained lead ranging from 0.003 mg/L
(Salt/Sand/Rainwater) to 0.05 mg/L (Distilled Water). The solutions
containing the lead wheel weight registered lead ranging from 0.189
mg/L (Rainwater) to 385 mg/L (Dilute Vinegar Solution). See data
table II. All results listed in the data above were rotated on a
table for 18 hours according to the EPA Toxic Characteristic
Leaching Protocol Test (TCLP). The EPA mandates TCLP testing
protocol and analysis to simulate landfill conditions and is
designed to determine which specific contaminants, such as lead,
identified by the US EPA, could potentially leach from landfills.
The TCLP procedure is also designed to determine the mobility
potential of hazardous heavy metals, such as lead, present in solid
and liquid wastes. The analyses completed by the UHL of our experimental lead wheel
weight testing solutions lead us to believe that significant measurable amounts
of soluble lead was present in all of the non-control and test
solutions listed above. In particular, we would like to note that
lead wheel weight test 1-10, simulating a typical EPA defined TCLP
landfill leachate condition, yielded an
astonishing 385 mg/Liter (385 PPM or 385,000 PPB) lead concentration
in solution. During the UHL testing 18 hour rotation time frame this
particular 14 gram lead wheel weight dissolved more than 0.3 gram
weight into a TCLP formulated dilute acetic acid solution. Surveys
were given to families in our town before and after our educational
piece. Results of the surveys showed a 21% increase in knowledge
about what a wheel weight is. There was also a 21% increase in
identification of lead as the metal in wheel weights. A 27% increase
was found in understanding the potential negative environmental
impact of lead wheel weights. An unexpected result was the slight
decrease in the percentage of people willing to pay more for an
environmentally friendly wheel weight. This may have been caused by
current poor economic conditions. People didn’t know how much more
steel wheel weights would cost them. See data table III. After
educational efforts at tire service centers, there was a 33%
increase in knowledge of non-lead balancing alternatives. There was
a 52% increase in knowledge of environmental issues associated with
lead wheel weights by tire service center staff. There was also an
increase in the number of centers that would be willing to
voluntarily switch to non-lead wheel weights. See data table IV.
|
|
Answer:
During the initial testing, we were surprised that the dilute
vinegar/lead wheel weight solution immediately turned black when the
indicator that was used to identify the presence of lead was added
to the solution. This immediate change indicated a high level of
lead. We didn’t think it would be that high. We did not expect the
control samples containing no lead wheel weights or the samples with
steel wheel weights to have any measurable lead concentration, even
at low levels. When we received the test results from the UHL, we
were surprised yet again at the extremely high level of lead in the
dilute vinegar solution. We were also surprised at the large number
of tire service center technicians who did not know the dangers of
lead in wheel weights. We saw people working in the tire service
centers with black hands. We wondered if it was lead dust. We even
saw someone eating with dirty hands after working with lead wheel
weights. We were surprised that they weren’t worried about this. We
also didn’t expect that we would find that so few tire facilities
carried alternatives to lead wheel weights. In the survey of
families we were very surprised that after our education there was a
slight decrease in the percentage of people who said they were
willing to pay more for an alternative wheel weight. |
|
Answer:
We learned what wheel weights are and how they are used. We learned
why lead is used for this purpose. We learned of the potential
hazards lead poses to humans and the environment. We learned that
people in our community had little awareness of possible dangers
from lead wheel weights. From our research we learned that landfills
contain acetic acid producing bacteria.
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/hac/landfill/html/ch2.html ) Our
experiments suggest that the lead in wheel weights readily reacts
with acetic acid present in our test solutions and the dilute acid
present in rainwater (pH=5.5) to produce toxic highly mobile soluble
lead compounds.
(http://www.smartenergy4kids.org/lead.solubility.html)
(http://www.silver-colloids.com/Tables/Solubility_Rules.html) Our
lead wheel weight experiments results suggest that a very small
amount of measurable lead (grams) can react under various
environmental conditions to form water soluble lead compounds. If
lead becomes mobile under natural environmental conditions then it
could potentially enter the environment and our drinking water
reserves through leaching and surface water runoff. Because the
accidental deposition of unregulated lead wheel weights is occurring
on our nation’s highways, we believe that environmental levels of
lead could increase due to the formation of soluble lead compounds,
This is important for everyone to know because discarded and road
deposited lead wheel weights can end up in a landfill or are subject
to acid rain, salt, sand and snow. As our UHL test results suggest,
lead from wheel weights can potentially form soluble lead compounds
that are carried off by street water runoff. We think that lead
contamination of any kind should not be tolerated. We also learned
that the tire service centers were willing to listen to our concerns
and were open to the possibility of using non-lead wheel weights.
However, the main area of concern for both consumers and tire
service centers is the cost associated with making the change. We
also were pleased to learn that our project has made an impact on
our local government and State Representatives. It is exciting to
know that because of our project and Environmental Summit three
bills have been introduced in the Iowa State Legislature and that
the City of |
|
Answer:
We recommend that the same testing protocol should be duplicated
with very small particles of lead because according to Robert Root’s
study “Lead Loading of Streets by Motor Vehicle Weights” lead wheel
weights are ground into very small pieces when motor vehicles run
over them. Dr. Root’s advise in his letter stated “as the size of
the particle decreases the size of the surface area increases more
than the volume of the lead particle such that smaller particles
have a larger reactive surface than large particles.” He suggested
that we should increase the surface area of the lead wheel weight by
filing lead wheel weights with a mill file and using the filings in
any future lead wheel weight solubility experiments. After the tests
were completed, Dr. Wichman stated, “Based
on these results one can determine that various conditions could
result in leaching of lead from wheel weights. How that models into
contamination of groundwater and/or surface water requires more
research.” The lead wheel weight testing to determine the solubility
of lead under various conditions is a logical step to enhance the
understanding of how hazardous lead could be released into the
environment. Further research is needed to show exactly which lead
compounds were formed by the lead wheel weight in the various
testing solutions. This would lead to greater understanding of how
the lead in wheel weights contributes to environmental
contamination. Further testing would be needed to prove if lead
wheel weights deposited in landfills form the deadly compound lead
acetate. More experiments could be done to verify how many lead
wheel weights are actually deposited on |
|
Answer:
We have identified three keys to solving the lead wheel weight
problem: 1) Educate the citizens, community leaders, and tire
service owners about the hazards of lead in wheel weights and the
alternative materials that can be used in wheel weights, 2) craft a
bill to phase out the sale and installation of lead wheel weights,
and 3) work with legislators, the IDNR, policy making and
environmental committees to encourage them to support the bill to
become law. Michael Green, Director of the Center for Environmental
Health stated, “Wheel weights have been identified as the largest
new route of lead releases into the environment. By moving the
industry away from leaded wheel weights, we are helping to keep the
lead out of our kids’ drinking water.” (www.ceh.org, August 20,
2008) If we don’t phase out the sale and use of lead in wheel
weights, people and wildlife in our community will suffer from the
health hazards caused by lead. |
|
Answer:
Barr, Linda. Personal Interview. 8/29/08. Caravanos, J. Weiss, A. Blaise, M. and Rudolph Jaeger. “A survey of spatially distributed exterior dust
lead loadings in |
|
Answer:
At the beginning of the project all of the team members did
background research on wheel weights and lead. Andrea studied the
alternatives to lead in wheel weights, Justin studied the history of
wheel weights, Brennan studied the health effects of lead, and Jathan studied the environmental effects of
lead. From this we learned our facts and it told us where to go in
terms of the project. We started our project by going as a team to
car dealers and tire service centers. Dust samples collected from tire
service work trays tested positive for lead. On the car lots, we
identified wheel weights and talked to the salespeople about our project.
After learning the facts we split up to work on parts of the project.
Andrea and Jathan worked on organizing the
testing. Lead wheel weight testing kits and procedures were
researched. Testing protocols were discussed and decided upon by all
team members. Preliminary lead testing was conducted by all team
members at Andrea’s home. The University of Iowa Hygienics Lab (UHL) was contacted by Andrea and
Jathan. Jathan
corresponded with Dr. Wichman concerning
the wheel weight lead testing protocol. Justin and Brennan worked on
organizing community education and legislative lobbying. Justin
designed display posters and created them with the help of the team.
Each team member arranged for team presentations within the
community. Brennan and Justin created a brochure explaining why lead
wheel weights should be phased out. All team members participated in
the five Lead Wheel Weight Community Awareness presentations. Each
member wrote letters to interested community members and state
legislators. Jathan wrote a letter to Dr.
Robert Root. All team members helped create surveys to find out what
individuals and tire stores know about lead wheel weights. All team
members distributed surveys and evaluated the responses. Brennan
emailed and phoned legislators Kaufmann, Bolkcom, and Willems.
Our school held an environmental summit for state legislators and
West Branch leaders. Brennan made phone calls to local officials to
get information about the number of vehicles in our community.
Andrea gathered information on alternatives to give us the best
recommendation for tire service stations. At the end the entire team
worked together to develop answers to the questions. |
|
Answer:
Our
team worked together by holding meetings to identify and distribute
tasks and developing timelines, emailing what we needed to get done,
meeting with auto service centers, and presenting to community
organizations. We
communicated through email and at weekly meetings. Our regular
meetings were important for distributing assignments, sharing
information and scheduling the next team activities. All team
members applied to be provided access to a common meeting place at
our local recreation center and were assigned a team meeting room
for the duration of the project. We also got together at school
and worked on the project. We met 1-2 times each week for
most of the project. We
divided the work and met to share our findings and make
suggestions. We worked
together to answer the questions and put together the mission
folder. |
|
Who
did your team contact for help?
Answer:
While we were researching our project we contacted Linda Barr, Chief
Waste Minimization Branch of the US EPA and Theresa Stiner of the Iowa Department of Natural
Resources to learn about current National and State regulations
concerning lead wheel weights. We contacted Dr. Robert Root to get
information about the study he conducted. Our teacher put us in
touch with Dr. Michael Wichman of the
|
|
Answer:
We are working toward making our solution a reality. We gave
presentations to the City Council, the |
Team Dead Weight Suggests A Community Model To Phase In Lead Free Wheel Weights. All communities benefit if lead in wheel weights is phased out. If a safe substance is used in wheel weights, lead is eliminated from entering the environment. There is a solution to the problem. Replicating our model in other communities can be accomplished: 1) through surveys, brochures and presentations to increase awareness of citizens, policy makers, and tire service owners about the hazards of lead wheel weights and the alternative of installing lead free wheel weights; 2) by crafting bills to phase out the installation of lead wheel weights; and 3) by working with legislators, the DNR, and environmental committees to encourage them to support the bills to become law. Ultimately, our goal is to eliminate the lead in wheel weights. To accomplish this, we recommend replication by communities that share our vision. Our website, <www.leadzero.org>, informs the public about the hazards of lead wheel weights. For communities to proceed with the project, we recommend conducting research to learn of health problems associated with lead wheel weights. Success includes the need to: 1) establish partnerships with research facilities to complete lead solubility testing; 2) create educational materials to improve community awareness; 3) work cooperatively with community decision makers to phase out lead wheel weights on city vehicles; 4) contact state policy makers to craft a bill to present to legislative committees; and 5) know a significant difference can be made in the community.
We began working on our issue in August.
The time required depends on: 1) establishing partnerships with
scientists, tire centers, and policy makers; 2) making presentations to
community citizens; 3) contacting legislators; and 4) once the legislative
process begins, contacting policy makers. Commitment, dedication, and
persistence are key components for success. Currently, ![]() to express individual lead wheel weight concerns. Please click here for Iowa Senate emails Please click here for Iowa House emails Please click here for United States Senate emails Please click here to write your United States Congressman
Study conducted by West Branch Iowa 7th grade Science Team "Dead Weight" February 27, 2009. A special thank you to our science team advisor Dr. Hector Ibarra, Dr. Michael D. Wichman, UIHL Iowa City Iowa, Dr. Robert A. Root and eCybermission.org |